Members:
Join | Forgot your password?
Tattersalls Top RightBaileys Top Right

Latest News

Owner Bates unsuccessful in bid to appeal Dromahane demotion

Owner Bates unsuccessful in bid to appeal Dromahane demotion

Owner Billy Bates has been unsuccessful in his appeal to have the decision of the stewards at the Doneraile point-to-point in Dromahane overturned following a hearing at the offices of the IHRB.

Bates’ horse Noreen Bawn, who subsequently sold for €220,000, had crossed the line in front on her debut in the Goffs Punchestown four-year-old mares maiden at the Cork venue in late April, however following a stewards enquiry following the race, the daughter of Jeremy was demoted to second, with Richard Black’s Tucanae instead promoted to race winner.

The full summary of the appeal hearing can be viewed below:

On the day, following the running of the Goffs Punchestown Sale 4-Y-O Mares Maiden Race, the Stewards enquired into possible interference involving Tucanae ridden by Mr. L.J. Murphy, placed second and Noreen Bawn ridden by Mr. M.J. O’Connor, placed first, where it appeared Noreen Bawn caused interference to Tucanae.
 
Having considered the evidence, the Stewards, using their powers under Regulation 32(i)(b), were satisfied that Noreen Bawn had improved her placing in relation to Tucanae as a result of this interference and consequently reversed the placings of those horses.
 
The grounds of Appeal lodged by Mr. Bates were that the Stewards were wrong to conclude that Noreen Bawn had improved her placing as a result of the interference.
 
Evidence was heard from Mr. Bates, Mr. Brian Jordan (Trainer), on behalf of the appellant and Mr. Bernard Smullen, Stewards Secretary on behalf of the IHRB. The Committee were also furnished with a written submission made by Mr. O’Connor. 
 
In his evidence Mr. Bates stated that he had not been at the point the interference was deemed to have occurred but was of the view that Noreen Bawn had spooked at the spectators and had to be corrected by Mr O’Connor. He conceded that the horse had moved across the track but was of the view that the other rider did not have to stop riding or correct his horses’ stride.
 
Mr. Jordan advised that he was watching the race from a side on angle. Mr Jordan stated that in his opinion Noreen Bawn had inconvenienced herself by veering from the crowd and that the best horse won the race on the day.
 
Mr. Smullen stated that he watched the race from the finish line with a head on view of the last fence where the interference occurred. He stated that Noreen Bawn had moved across the track and that manoeuvre had caused Tucanae to move out and resulted in that horse being outside the wing of the fence a couple of strides from the fence with the result that Mr. Murphy had to correct his horse to ensure that he could jump the final fence. 
 
The Appeals Body also viewed a recording of the race but noted that the angle of the footage meant it was of limited assistance.
 
Having considered the evidence, the Appeals Body found on the balance of probabilities that no error had been made in the determination of the enquiry by the Stewards and on that basis dismissed the appeal and confirmed the result as amended by the Stewards to read as follows.
 
First:                 Tucanae
Second:            Noreen Bawn
Third:               Methodtothemagic
Fourth:             At First Glance
 
They ordered that €200 of the deposit be refunded to Mr. Bates.
 


Search the Archives

recent news story
The David Christie-trained six-year-old was found to have tested positive for a substance above the permitted threshold.
recent news story
The new season will get underway at Toomebridge on October 5th with the Mid-Antrim point-to-point.
recent news story
The 21-year-old was sidelined for the entire point-to-point season following complications after a T12 vertabrae fracture
recent news story
Mikey O'Connor's appeal against the severity of his ban was heard at the IHRB offices on Thursday 18th July. For more click here...
recent news story
The handlers will each recieve a E1,000 voucher to be used at stores sales in either 2019 or 2020.
recent news story
The Wexford outfit went into seven figures as they bought 20 horses for the new point-to-point season.
recent news story
The own-brother to the Cheltenham hero has gone into training with Ellmarie Holden after being bought at the Derby sale.
recent news story
The former point-to-point rider sold his first horse at a store sale for E38,000 and is looking to build on that.
recent news story
A look back on each meeting during the 2018/19 point-to-point season.
recent news story
Fomer chairman of the Cork - Waterford point-to-point committee J.J. Harty passed away earlier this week
recent news story
Mary Tyner is raising funds for the Injured Jockeys Fund in memory of her son Jack Tyner who sadly passed away following a heavy fall 8 years ago.
recent news story
Five Star Getaway disqualified following his victory in the five-year-old geldings' maiden at Courtown on 07/04/19.
recent news story
Colin Bowe once again signed for the most expensive horse bound for the pointing fields on day two at Goffs.
recent news story
The Monbeg team parted with almost one million euro as they bought 22 horses on a day of big prices.
recent news story
The 40th Annual Irish Field Point-to-Point Awards took place on Saturday 8th June at the Hotel Minella, Co. Tipperary.
recent news story
Maxine O'Sullivan rode her 50th winner between-the-flags last Sunday
recent news story
Jack O'Grady got off the mark at just the third time of asking at Ballingarry last Sunday and talks about how he got involved here.
recent news story
Rob James rode his 200th winner between-the-flags on Sunday
recent news story
Ken Parkhill bred four individual winners including Begoodtoyourself, a winner on the final day of the season.
recent news story
That Fairyhouse victory was one of the in hunter chase company for Gordon Elliott's charge.
recent news story
The Coolmore stallion won the title with 35 winners while Milan took second place with 30 winners.
recent news story
Sam Curlings` charge set to collect both Champion Pointer and Champion mare award.
recent news story
45 winners secures the handlers title for Colin Bowe
recent news story
The veteran On The Fringe wins the Listowel Hunters Chase at 14!
recent news story
Maxine O'Sullivan seals the Ladies Champion Title with success in the penultimate race of the season.
recent news story
A tally of 16 wins for the season secures the novice title for Michael O`Sullivan.
recent news story
The win marks the Wexford natives third consecutive Champion Rider Title.
recent news story
Thirteen wins apiece for Longhouse Music and Kruzhlinin sees them share the title as race goes down to the wire.
recent news story
The victory marks O'Connor's ninth Southern Title and his second Senior Title.
recent news story
Wonderful Charm secures success under Sam Waley Cohen, with Chosen Dream back in sixth.
recent news story
Shane Fenelon rode a double at Stradbally last Saturday and talks about how it all came about here.
recent news story
Derek O`Connor is set to take his 11th consecutive Western title this year.
recent news story
The Champion Pointer contest continues to heat up as each of the leading pair record their 12th success.
recent news story
Barry O'Neill was crowned eastern champion for the 2018/19 season as that region finishes at Stradbally.
recent news story
The Sean McParlan-trained favourite won his fourth race of the season in the Frank Fitzsimmons Memorial.
recent news story
Donnchadh Doyle's Bartlemy four-year-old winner claimed top billing as over 120 Irish Pointers were offered for sale.
recent news story
20-year-old Diamuid Moloney recorded the first success of his career last Sunday and discusses his background here.
recent news story
Kruzhlinin won his second race of the weekend, whilst Longhous Music was among the winners at Loughrea.
recent news story
Barry O'Neill is now just two winners adrift of Derek O'Connor in the sourthern region following a treble at Ballindenisk.
recent news story
Jamie Codd won his fourth northern title following a treble at Loughanmore including a 10th of the season for Kruzhlinin.
recent news story
Ronan McNally enjoyed a day to remember at Hexham on Monday when his stable veteran See Double You won his tenth races at the ripe old age of 15.
EU SIFPITMEuropean UnionOfig Fiontair Aitiuil
© Irish Point to Point Services Ltd, 2014. All rights reserved. Grangeclare West, Kilmeague, Naas, Co Kildare
Cookie Policy | Privacy Policy
Hosting and Development by HostIreland